No one ever knows if the real Walter lived or not and that is sad. Christine Collins was released after ten days after Hutchins admitted that he was not her son and she filed a lawsuit against the Los Angeles Police Department. Always stranger than fiction. Angelina Jolie stars as Christine Collins, whose 9-year-old son, Walter, went missing in March 1928. I can’t imagine a worse pain than not knowing what happened to your child. Sadly, this kind of cruel behaviour towards anyone who dared to question the authorities – even with overwhelming evidence on their side – isn’t unique for the times she lived in, and probably not just those times either. The point was to get rid of someone you just didn’t want around. (Courtesy author) There are many variations on the story, but the Brothers Grimm summed up in concise form the main components of a typical changeling story from mid-19th-century Germany: A mother had her child taken from the cradle by elves. The cop had a lot of weight and tried to make the poor lady a “nut” since their police force could not find out the truth. And to just placate them until they calmed down. Unbelievable this was allowed to happen. https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/352/the-ghost-of-bobby-dunbar. So very sad. Changeling (2008) on IMDb: Plot summary, synopsis, and more ... Gustav then tells Christine the story of how Davis became chief and his first action was to give the ... who he calls a real classy lady. No one may ever know. It’s terrible that the police tried to insist the other boy was her son. lol. The bizarre true story behind the ‘Changeling’. Obviously, she couldn’t unjust ignore the boy and she must have been very concerned that his parents would be terribly worried about their son. I haven’t heard this story before. She calls the L.A.P.D. So often it’s the families of the victim who end up paying the price. The way Mrs. Collins was treated was a perfect example of gaslighting. I have a 10 year old son who has a great passion for the child’s voice. to her own detriment when it tries to pass off an obvious impostor as her missing child. Now, 80 years later, director Clint Eastwood revives the story in his movie "Changeling." What Jones did, what the child did, and of course want the murderers of Jones’ real son did. Jones accused her of shirking her duty as a mother. Changeling is a non-stat raising, full-length visual novel about love, ... Story The human world accepted as reality is only a thin veneer under which lies a world of supernatural creatures, entities, and people. A senseless, bizarre, and unbelievable true crime story that occurred in Los Angeles. Others were bullied into silence. STORY Scotland, 1919. Sad but true, Patricia. As horrible as that is, and it is one of the worst things that could happen to a person, I imagine it’s even worse when you don’t know what happened to your child, or if they’re alive or dead. In European folklore and folk belief, a changeling is the offspring of a fairy, troll, elf, or other legendary creature that has been secretly left in the place of a human child. It’s so sad. That adds a lot of perspective to the story…thanks! Grief-stricken mother Christine Collins (Angelina Jolie) takes on the L.A.P.D. https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/352/the-ghost-of-bobby-dunbar. I wonder what happened to the changeling? No one ever said the boy, (Walter) was murdered. . October 28, 2008 at 12:40 pm (Uncategorized) This is the last set of photos related to the Wineville Chicken Coop Murders (the true story behind the film, “Changeling”) that I plan to post on this blog. If you have any information on this case, please contact the LAPD at 1-877-527-3247. In this day and age, being a detective does require more training than the average beat cop, but I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if something like this happened today, especially now that kids are being taught how to steal identities by watching tv. Their true skin is usually grey or pale white, and their facial features are blank slates … The Changeling Houses Moves To Hollywood As the years passed, a popular horror film chronicled the haunting there, and the 1980 film The Changeling, starring Academy Award Winner George C. Scott opened to rave reviews. Corruption runs rampant and they know most attorneys in the United States will not fight the battle as the attorneys cannot make any money from the Federal Government. Thanks for your insightful comment, Dave, and for your years of service. Happening so long ago I hope that no law enforcement officer or agency would let in any way, even slightly, something so cruel as this happen today, politically,morally,ethically or just plain evil. Hunter had worked as a … Yes, the 2008 film is based on a true story, of the real Christine Collins. Changeling contains a number of anachronisms, some of which are, surprisingly, quite obvious. VOA's Penelope Poulou has more. When I saw Thorax on his debut on MLP I was delighted with the idea of a Changeling seeking acceptance. The story is set in 1928 (until about 1935), so it is rather sloppy writing for it to include expressions such as ‘don’t go there’ (popularized in the 1980s), ‘put out an APB’, (‘all points bulletins’ originated in the 1960s), ‘a sandwich in the fridge… Hutchins, the boy that impersonated spent more than two years in the Iowa State Training School for Boys in Eldora, Iowa, as a result of his actions. I can’t imagine being that poor mother, consumed by the loss and then deceived again and again. I have heard of this story and it’s just so appalling. Learn how your comment data is processed. As horrible as this may sound, I have a cousin who’s married to a police officer and even he admits that the police are not always the best people to solve a mystery; everyday crimes, yes, but something like this is different. History! Then, five months after Walter’s disappearance, there was a chilling new development. It was this pretext that Northcott used to bring Clark from Bladworth to the U.S. Absolutely chilling to think about the things that happen in the world around us that’s NOT fiction! We probably don’t want to know. I don’t think however that anybody on this board was trying to make excuses for it, they just couldn’t comprehend why trusted authorities would do what they did. He was just watching over her. Your email address will not be published. Swallowing the Camel has moved! The convict was clearly taking the blame. Now after almost 80 years, that mystery has been … Either way it’s a sad story. She looked for her son until her death. Single mother Christine Collins (Angelina Jolie) returns from work to find her nine-year-old son Walter (Gattlin Griffith) gone. It was horrifying that the LAPD could treat someone like that. A changeling, also historically referred to as an auf or oaf, is a human-like creature found in folklore and folk religion throughout Europe.A changeling was believed to be a fairy child that had been left in place of a human child stolen by the fairies. When she is assigned to work overtime on Saturday at … The man had little regard for human beings so he would not remember details and would mix up which boy had blue eyes and which one had brown….those 2 had no regard for human life. Sometimes the lore describes fairies doing thi "Once upon a time, there was a child whom the goblins came to steal, and once upon a time, there was a child whom the goblins left behind." Collins continued to search for her son until her own death on December 8, 1964. So sad how this mother was treated! Also wish to add. A massive investigation found no sign of Walter until five months later, when a boy found in Illinois claimed to be the missing child. Christine Collin's (Angelina Jolie) 9-year-old son, Walter, was abducted on March 10, 1928. And that wasn’t the only thing strange. Even the kid confessed. And a lot of the doctors from that era are training the doctors today. I made a boo-boo. Methods of returning a Changeling How could this story not touch you. The fear of a “breakdown in society” was strong and the people’s trust in law and the keepers of it was required. These patients were given large doses of LSD, put into insulin induced comas for weeks/months at a time, given Paige Russel electro shocks, and were subjected to having to listen to pre-recorded tapes playing very loud and endlessly with headphones to the patients ears while strapped down. PEOPLE.com and the … The behavior is quite a bit more than that… it is downright evil and criminal. fool!” he apparently told her. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The sheer manipulation and power is terrifying. It’s almost as though you’re making excuses for the time, a kind of moral relativism. This is horrible! She was a single mother in the 1920’s which was looked down upon and the average male especially in some sort of law enforcement would treat her as an “hysterical woman”. The Changeling (1980). Christine Collins, a manager at a telephone company, sent her nine-year-old son Walter to the movies. The police were cruel in their treatment of Mrs. Collins. That poor woman! One of the enduring questions behind Angelina Jolie ‘s film Changeling is why a little boy pretended to be a distraught mother’s missing son. She needed a hospital, not a prison cell. All involved in any way have answered or will answer for this tragedy. I guess they were too eager to solve the case rather than get the truth. She never saw him again, though the Los Angeles police (LAPD) would have loved to convince her otherwise. Jones was definitely feeling the pressure, but he must have known Christine was telling the truth, since he told her to “try the boy out.”. Obviously. Killers can tell you details on everything. Heart breaking, as a mother just horrible❤️. Charles, I agree that it was pure evil, what the police did to Christine Collins. This story is VERY good, pretty damn stressful, but fantastic payoff. Bizarre reaction from police for sure. When little Walter didn’t return, Collins was at first convinced her son’s disappearance was an act of retribution against the child’s father, a conman and robber who was serving time at Folsom State Prison for armed robbery. I am sorry for the pain the family has gone through. Most definitely! terrible awful story … I wonder how many times this happens. I guess there must have been some photos where it was more difficult to tell them apart. I don’t think there ever will be, since this case is so old. Sad but true. It’s just too bizarre not to be used for fiction. They were labeled “crazy” and some lived the rest of their lives out in these places. Have you heard this scary true story before? I’m glad she had friends to stand by her and that she was eventually let out of the institution. I know of several cases from that time period when women who were temporarily depressed or distraught due to the death of a loved one or other traumatic event were institionalized and treated for mental disorders with massive amounts of drugs and shock treatment because family members and authorities didn’t know what to do with them. Count your selves like. All victims were part of a CIA experiment in conjunction with the Canadian Government. Sad sad state of affairs. The Changeling, at least in the classical sense, probably stems from British folklore, and specifically stories surrounding fairies. It reminds me of a short story I read a long time ago I think it was called a “room with a view”. What STRANGE things happen in this world! As the bizarre imposter story unfolded (which inspired the 2008 film, Changeling, starring Angelina Jolie), police unearthed a serial killing case, which they believed may hold the … The changeling had ran away from an abusive situation where his own mother was neglectful. Thank you for your post. I’ve heard a lot of bad stories about the LAPD, but this is one of the most egregious. Paranormal news, articles, real ghost stories, UFO, aliens and everything from A to Z of the unexplained, strange & odd. Clint Eastwood directs Oscar® winner Angelina Jolie and Oscar® nominee John Malkovich in a riveting and unforgettable true story. Three weeks later, she returned to the LAPD to say she was absolutely certain the runaway was not her son. I’m not making that up. Jones was insistent, so Collins struggled to convince herself the strange boy was her son…for THREE weeks. Changeling is a 2008 American mystery crime drama film directed, produced, and scored by Clint Eastwood and written by J. Michael Straczynski, that explores child endangerment, female disempowerment, political corruption, mistreatment of mental health patients, and the repercussions of violence. As it turned out, the young man had often done this pretense before. His eyes weren’t even the same colour! Single moms had no choice. Very much so. He is extremely intelligent in a philosophical thoughtful way, and he gets justly cross that children are not heard- or given a voice. It was heartbreaking and infuriating. The story reflects Christine Collins’ attempts to recover her … If this mother has any descendants, they should sue the LAPD for the court awarded amount the mother never received from her lawsuit; WITH INTEREST AND PENALTIES!!!! You mean Changeling , the 2008 Angelina Jolie movie?Because...it. Of course technology today would prevent this but it still makes me sick to know that anyone or anything ever could have been so heartless and cruel no matter what the times, past present or future. Sarcasm aside, this has always been a sad, scary story. Let’s discuss that. ©2020 J.H. I’ve seen that happen in too many missing child cases. It is the factual account of a mother whose little boy disappeared, and of a corrupt Los … MoncrieffWebsite By Elise Epp Design and Amanda Weber. By Amsterdamsel DIAMOND, Henderson , Nevada. If other reader’s havn’ t seen these kind of acts for your selves. It’s Mrs. Collins who was responsible for calling to light the horrendous state of affairs with law enforcement that led to recovery of at least two children and answers for other parents as to what became of their children. This may be a “MAN’S WORLD” but women are the glue that holds it all together. Scary isn’t it? If any story proves the adage “truth is stranger than fiction,” it’s this one. Heartbreaking that this poor woman had to endure the dismissive police. Who’s your Favorite Star Under 35? She never really found out. jones figured he could get his way if he kept pushing. In God’s eyes, women have real worth and value as HIS children; too bad men are blind. This is beyond abhorrent. It is extremely bizarre, but I swear it’s true! For more about the real story behind Changeling, pick up PEOPLE Magazine on newsstands now. Yes, that’s criminal. I’ve had worse happen to me. I wonder if the Family will ever see the Money the mother was awarded from the Police Department. When Collins arrived at the happy little reunion the LAPD had arranged, she saw immediately that the boy wasn’t her son. Swallowing the Camel has moved! You mean Changeling, the 2008 Angelina Jolie movie? Yes, when I was researching and writing this one, I focused on how cruel the police were, but the little boy was actually quite awful as well, though I’m sure he didn’t understand the consequences of his actions. The Real-Life Damage of Changeling Lore April 15, 2013 by Chelsea Martin A lot of Changeling lore focuses on the perspective of the parent: the frightening, unspeakable thought that the child they’re caring for may not be their own, and the strange, complicated lengths that they go through to get their “real… In a small village on the Cavan/Leitrim border, there was a man who was said to have been taken as a baby by the Faeries but was returned 10 years later much to his family’s joy and amazement. Back in the 1920s, very few people talked about improprieties and abuse of adults toward children. He resembled Walter, but Walter he most definitely was not. Can you imagine how painful and awkward it must have been for Mrs. Collins having a boy for 3 weeks that she knew wasn’t her son and trying to find a common ground with him. But to go to the point of having the mother committed for not ‘settling for the next best thing’! Aside from the potential damage done to her, what about the other mother who would have been frantically searching for her own missing son! I really believed it was true and if the ghost knew that you knew, you were in trouble! 19th-century image of a faerie changeling baby. She won, but never saw a penny of the judgement. It’s worth following up on. The LAPD was apparently corrupt and eager to improve their image by shoving an orphan on the poor mother. I wonder if the LAPD back in that era received bonuses for closing cases; or maybe Jones was under pressure to improve the number of closed cases…???? Today forensics is superior to the 20’s when I doubt there was nothing more than dental records. Changeling Appearance. Not Mine: A Scottish Changeling Story 13th June 2019 23rd June 2019 Amelia Starling Folklore , Short stories , Writing In preparation for a field trip, I was browsing through the Statistical Accounts of Scotland to learn about some of the towns I would be passing through. There is a whole corruption of children in the US. Your great grandparents might have been alive then! Spoilers: Changeling - The Real Story Behind Eastwood's Movie Sacha Howells 11/07/2008. Rather than back down and admit his mistake, Jones got angry. It’s called CPS who along with the judges cops etc. Changeling is a film written by J. Michael Straczynski and directed by Clint Eastwood (Million Dollar Baby).It was distributed in 2008 by Universal Pictures, and stars Angelina Jolie (), John Malkovich … Why would a police officer say, “try the boy out” Have the Mother Committed when she brought in dental records and multiple Neighbors, all claiming this isn’t Walter. Upon the boy's arrival t… Our Minnesota story is about Jacob Wetterling. There’s no closure. The apparent changeling could also be a stock, a glamorized piece of wood that would soon appear to grow sick and die. I know the film and own the DVD. the hubby was associated with or had ticked off in Folsom. Since the story is narrated through Martha, the reader is not privy to Ivy's secret thoughts, but we learn what kind of child she is--free-spirited, creative, imaginative. I am struck by the fact that many of you describe the behavior of the police, most particularly that of police Capt JJ Jones, as “bizarre” or “strange”. Sounds like the worst occur carelessly OOC or intentionally at the hands of a shitty DM (like in the notorious airship story) but my experience of an IC, unexpected changeling outing probably saved my PC and also my IRL sanity in the process. Good God call it for what it is-EVIL!!! Them days it was safe to keep your door unlocked or most children alone and everything was safe. Esp white cop on blacks or Hispanics. They falsify medical records, claim records, and official documents through all three agencies. It was twelve years old, and from its eyes and the fact that it had all of its senses, one could have thought that it was a real child. I feel for those poor parents. Changeling Tale is a story-driven, transformation-themed visual novel featuring eleven romance options and many immersive transformations, all determined by your choices. Is it any updates in the case now? The script was based on real-life events, specifically the 1928 Wineville Chicken Coop Murders in Mira Loma, California. J.J. Jones’s response. Welcome to my blog, Nan! Mrs. Collins had nothing to lose by standing up publicly. Many didn’t know what to do to find their children. . It was common knowledge across America that ,” You can’t fight city hall.” It was easy to have anybody committed for any reason at all. The let my abusive husband throw me out of my home and destroy my life and my children’s got their paychecks. How incredibly horrible. According to the Los Angeles Times, Jones allegedly accused Collins of shirking her duty as a mother and trying to make fools of the police. I have two boys and can’t imagine the strength it took to survive and fight this. “You are the most cruel-hearted woman I’ve ever known. This case, in many ways, is a sign of the times. Clint Eastwood's "Changeling" made me feel sympathy, and then anger, and then back around again. After exchanging letters and photographs, an overjoyed Collins agreed to pay for the child’s train ticket to Los Angeles. I am overcome by a feeling of helplessness when I read accounts like these. "Try the boy out." His name was Arthur Hutchins. I believe Jones had everything to do with it. Reminds me of a “This American Life” story, “The Ghost of Bobby Dunbar.” I have a friend who is a doctor and was trained in the 1950’s and they were taught that most women were, or could easily be, hysterical. The boys don’t even look alike. Yikes, that’s absolutely horrible, Alison. A changeling is the child of a supernatural being that is switched for a human baby. I’m so sorry to hear about your mother. Huge recommendation. Walter Collins Jr.’s ultimate fate is unknown, although it is believed that he was probably a victim of the sadistic serial killer Gordon Northcott, known to be active in that area at the time, in what became known as the Wineville Chicken Coop Murders. Not at all unusual or bizarre for the times . Its real, and it is happening even today. especially the one who let her down the most, and had her commited, how cruel, RIP to this mother who must have suffered beyond belief. While Gordon confessed to murdering Walter, he kept changing his story. Like all the other books in this series, The Changeling is super super spooky but also adds in a strong emotional element.. We're now at swallowingthecamel.wordpress.com. It is a real … At least in this case they didn’t treat her like a murderer. The 1980 film The Changeling is based on the paranormal events Russell Hunter ... Hunter claimed that a séance revealed the story of a sickly child who was heir to ... after with a light on. Truly sad and I feel for the mother and all the people still living who are haunted by this case. You likely “Lottery” onlookers alarm me almost as much as the police of the era. This tip line is completely anonymous.). Instead of apologizing to Collins, reimbursing the money she’d spent on the boy’s train ticket, and vowing to find her real son, Jones insisted she “try the boy out,” as if he were a new type of toothpaste rather than a child. Changeling contains a number of anachronisms, some of which are, surprisingly, quite obvious. I read a similar case where a young man pretended to be a long lost son and all the pain the people went through while trying to convince themselves he was the grown up version of their son. Thanks for commenting. Collins was finally released from the hospital TEN days after Hutchins confessed, and she immediately sued Jones and the LAPD. Ghosts, the paranormal, myths and legends, Nikolai Dzhumagaliev – Serial Killer and Cannibal Known as Metal Fang, Victim of Jack the Ripper: The Tortured Spirit of Mary Kelly, The Woman Who Rose From The Dead To Terrify Her Neighbours, Feng Shui: The Art of Attracting Money And Good Energy, Amazing Hopi Prophecy For The Future of Humanity, The Strange Disappearance Of Brian Schaffer, Theory: Fungus Ergot Caused Salem Witchcraft Persecutions, The Strange Case Of Ghost Hunt In Mogadore, Ohio, In Japan, Allowed To Grow Hybrids Of Humans And Animals, New Theory Suggests That We Travel To Parallel Universes When We Dream, Pyramids Discovered In Russia Twice As Old As Egyptian, Mummified Captain Found In Ghost Ship Drifting At Sea, Loveland Castle: One Of The Most Haunted Sites In Ohio.